A comfortable mattress makes all the difference in a good night's sleep. The right material and level of firmness remove sleeping pressure points and leave you feeling well-rested in the morning. Our partners at ConsumerAffairs researched the best mattress stores in Cincinnati to find the top sleep options at the most affordable prices.
Everyone deserves to make thoughtful, informed purchase decisions. The local guides provided on this website are free for consumers. WCPO may receive compensation from our partners. Learn more.
We spend nearly a third of our lives sleeping, so investing in a good mattress is a no-brainer for many consumers. With so many brands on the market, though, it's difficult to determine which is the best mattress in Cincinnati for you.
There are a few things that shoppers consider when choosing a mattress:
Firmness/Softness: Mattresses come in varying degrees of firmness, with many companies allowing you to customize the mattress to your specific tastes.
Pain Relief: If pain and pressure point relief is a priority for you, consider how different mattress materials and firmness might affect you. Memory foam and latex are great for back pain, though many experts recommend medium-firm to firm mattress for optimal pain relief. It’s essential to find a mattress that keeps your spine in alignment while sleeping to help reduce back pain.
Sleeping Position: A memory foam mattress or latex mattress is often the most comfortable for back sleepers, while stomach sleepers should opt for something a little firmer. Side sleepers, on the other hand, should err on the side of plushness, which lets them sink into the mattress and helps reduce pressure points.
Body Shape: Depending on the size and shape of your body frame, you may need more or less padding to keep your spine in alignment.
Another consideration is the type of material and style of the mattress. While innerspring mattresses are the most traditional choice, manufacturers now design multiple types of mattresses. Many people prefer the benefits of a memory foam mattress or hybrid mattress over traditional choices.
Popular mattress types in Cincinnati
A steel coil support system covered with plush padding
$700 - $1,200
Memory foam mattress
Soft foam that molds to your shape and allows cooling airflow
$600 - $1,200
A naturally bouncy material that provides extra support
Back and shoulder pain
$1,500 - $2,500
Innerspring support plus latex or memory foam padding
$1,200 - $2,000
Bed in a box vs. in-store mattresses
Mattress shopping has changed in recent years with the rise of mattress-in-a-box services. Unlike their brick-and-mortar competitors, online mattress companies operate purely online and ship the mattress to your home in a compact, vacuum-sealed box. Customers then open the inner bag and allow the mattress to expand to its full shape over a few hours.
Pros and cons of bed-in-a-box mattresses
Cost: By selling directly to customers, online mattress companies are often able to offer lower costs.
Convenience: Shopping for a mattress online allows you to search for multiple companies from the comfort of your home.
Trial periods: Although most mattresses come with trial periods, online mattress stores usually offer extended trial periods of 100 nights up to a year.
Limited mattress selection: Most online companies only sell their own brand and have a limited number of styles available.
Inability to test mattresses: Unlike visiting a traditional mattress store, you won’t have an opportunity to lie on a mattress to see how it feels until it arrives at your home.
Odor: Some Cincinnati residents complain about the mattress’s smell the first few days after unboxing.
Many consumers choose to purchase a mattress through these bed-in-a-box companies for the sake of lower price and convenience. Those who patronize traditional mattress stores usually prefer to support local businesses, discuss their options with a salesperson or test the mattress out in-store before buying.
With prices for a queen-size mattress ranging from $300 to upwards of $5,000, you usually get what you pay for when it comes to buying a mattress. The average price for a queen-size mattress is around $1,000, and you can expect to spend at least $600 for a quality mattress that lasts. Some mattress types are more expensive than others — expect to pay more for a latex mattress than a memory foam mattress.
The best time to buy a mattress from Cincinnati retailers is from February to May, which is when mattress retailers clear inventory to make room for the newest models. Online mattress stores may offer discounts during retail holidays like Black Friday and Cyber Monday.
There are often additional costs when purchasing a mattress. Depending on the type of bed, you may need a box spring or foundation. Memory foam mattresses do not require a box spring if you have a platform bed frame that provides adequate support. Many online companies offer free delivery or shipping, but some brick-and-mortar stores may charge a delivery fee of up to $150.
Mattress disposal in Cincinnati
Some companies provide free mattress removal when delivering your new mattress, though others may charge a fee for the service. Don’t pay extra for mattress removal if you live in Cincinnati city limits — you can request free bulk trash pick up (including mattress removal) by phone or the Fix It Cincy! mobile app, which lowers the total cost of replacing your old mattress.
How to buy a mattress in Cincinnati
Carefully research and evaluate any online or local company before purchasing a mattress. Be sure to check customer reviews from former clients to see if people are satisfied with their purchase and the company’s customer service.
Other factors to compare when choosing where to buy a mattress include:
Product warranty: Most companies offer at least a 10-year warranty on their mattresses, and some companies offer extended warranties that last as long as you own the mattress. Compare the length of warranties and ask if you’re responsible for shipping if you return a mattress for a warranty claim.
Return policies: It takes time to become accustomed to a mattress, so make sure the company you purchase from has a good return policy or trial period. Most online companies offer a trial period of at least 100 nights, during which time you can return the mattress for no charge.
Options: Some mattress companies, especially online mattress retailers, only offer one firmness level. Shop around and make sure the company you choose has the style and firmness level you prefer.
With the number of options, choosing a mattress can be daunting. It’s vital to make an informed purchase, though — buying a mattress is a decision that impacts how you feel each day and affects your overall quality of life. Taking care in your research ensures you are satisfied with your new mattress and the customer service you receive.
Saatva Mattress prides itself on “mattress buying made easy.” Choose your firmness level, ranging from plush to firm, and pair the mattress with the Saatva adjustable base to customize your sleeping experience. Cincinnati customers praise the ease of ordering, Saatva's satisfaction guarantee and the exceptional comfort of the mattress.
With several material options and price points available, Luma Sleep has something for everyone — including adjustable bases, linens and mattress toppers. The company offers free exchanges to ensure you're satisfied with the firmness of your mattress. In Cincinnati, customers seem particularly impressed with the company's excellent customer service.
Select Comfort - Sleep Number
Sleep Number believes in improving lives through comfortable sleep and advertises the most personalized sleep experience ever. The company has multiple mattress series to choose from, providing options for every budget and type of sleeper. Sleep Number customers in Cincinnati report that they are sleeping well on their new mattresses.
Purple Mattress approaches mattress design from a scientific perspective and seeks to offer comfort to all types of sleepers with their pressure-relieving gridded mattress. Keep the mattress for Purple’s 100-night sleep trial and return it for free if you aren't completely satisfied. Sleepers in Cincinnati say the mattress is very comfortable and soft.
Casper makes it easy to find the mattress that suits your needs by featuring multiple models with varying numbers of foam layers. These mattresses are among the most affordable options available online, but some customers in Cincinnati experience issues with the quality and comfort of their Casper mattress.
Nectar Mattresses are crafted from pressure-relieving memory foam and feature superior comfort and coolness. The company offers a 365-day trial period, a lifetime warranty and affordable financing. Most Cincinnati reviewers love their Nectar mattress and the customer service they received, with many observing that the mattress is firm yet comfortable.
Our partners independently research and analyze the companies mentioned in our guides and work with subject matter experts to add valuable information that helps consumers make smart purchase decisions. Our partners will not include companies on these guides that do not meet specific quality standards. The compensation we receive from our partners may impact how and where companies appear on our site, including the order in which they appear.
Our partners independently research companies, and use editorial discretion to award companies with special recognition (i.e. Best Value) based on their staff’s judgement or subject matter expert’s judgement. Our partners do this to help you identify companies that will meet your specific buying needs, and do not receive compensation for these designations.